| Year | Name | Award |
| 2024 | Tina Tinelli | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2022 | Ally Hall | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2022 | Asylin Weseman | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2013 | Ashley Wilkins | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2012 | Meghenn Jackson | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 2011 | Elizabeth Hicks | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2010 | Samantha Adams | NJCAA Honorable Mention All America |
| 2009 | Amy Baker | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2008 | Sarah Green | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 2007 | Jacquelyn D' Orsaneo | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2005 | Elizabeth Anderson | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2004 | Jenn Gappert | NJCAA Honorable Mention All America |
| 2003 | Catherine Gilbert | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2002 | Natash Rust | NJCAA Third Team All America |
| 2001 | Lindsay Ries | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2001 | Sheconda Douglas | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2001 | Lindsey Pies | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 2000 | Virginia Jorde | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 2000 | Sheconda Douglas | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1999 | Lorie Zamarripa | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1999 | Pollyanna Williams | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1998 | Elizabeth Trevino | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1998 | Lorie Zamarripa | NJCAA Honorable Mention All America |
| 1990 | Sandi Young | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1990 | Nikki Beall | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1990 | Suzanne Price | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1989 | Jennifer Bailey | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1989 | Misty Parr | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1989 | Nicole Vogel | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1988 | Jennifer Bailey | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1988 | Sarah Yates | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1988 | Jennifer Berg | NJCAA Second Team All America |
| 1986 | Sharon McAllister | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1985 | Sharon McAllister | NJCAA First Team All America |
| 1985 | Pam Jone Bellman | NJCAA Second Team All America |