| Year | Name | Award |
| 2023 | Kaitlyn Evans | NJCAA All America |
| 2023 | Nellie Gownley | NJCAA All America |
| 2023 | Lyndsey Miller | NJCAA All America |
| 2023 | Savanna Reitz | NJCAA All America |
| 2023 | Julia Sokolowski | NJCAA All America |
| 2022 | Autumn Foster-Fields | NJCAA All America |
| 2022 | Madison Hobbs | NJCAA All America |
| 2022 | Savanna Reitz | NJCAA All America |
| 2022 | Madison Shaner | NJCAA All America |
| 2022 | Elsa Skinner | NJCAA All America |
| 2019 | Lacey Hinkle | NJCAA All America |
| 2019 | Jordan Snyder | NJCAA All America |
| 2019 | Natalie Sonntag | NJCAA All America |
| 2019 | Bridgette Tayman | NJCAA All America |
| 2018 | Alyssa Baronella O' Toole | NJCAA All America |
| 2018 | Sofia Michael | NJCAA All America |
| 2018 | Madeline Szanyi | NJCAA All America |
| 2017 | Sofia Michael | NJCAA All America |
| 2017 | Emily Rowe | NJCAA All America |
| 2017 | Alyssa Yates | NJCAA All America |
| 2016 | Elaine Draper | NJCAA All America |
| 2016 | Emily Rowe | NJCAA All America |
| 2016 | Renee Ruppert | NJCAA All America |
| 2014 | Kathleen Gehrdes | NJCAA All America |
| 2013 | Brittanti Biddinger | NJCAA All America |
| 2013 | Meghenn Jackson | NJCAA All America |
| 2013 | Shannon O'Neal | NJCAA All America |
| 2012 | Sam Adams | NJCAA All America |
| 2012 | Meghenn Jackson | NJCAA All America |
| 2012 | Mary Milligan | NJCAA All America |
| 2012 | Karlee Zywusko | NJCAA All America |
| 2011 | Cloey Henchcliffe | NJCAA All America |
| 2011 | Erica McMahon | NJCAA All America |
| 2011 | Mary Milligan | NJCAA All America |
| 2010 | Jenny Miller | NJCAA All America |
| 2010 | Megan Schrum | NJCAA All America |
| 2009 | Kellie Kroneberger | NJCAA All America |
| 2009 | Andrea Zoolakis | NJCAA All America |
| 2008 | Brittany Griffin | NJCAA All America |
| 2008 | Bryanna Vohs | NJCAA All America |
| 2007 | Ashleigh Gender | NJCAA All America |
| 2007 | Springanne Hatfield | NJCAA All America |
| 2007 | Courtney Highsmith | NJCAA All America, National Offensive Player of the Year |
| 2007 | Sarah Maggio | NJCAA All America |
| 2007 | Kristine Schafer | NJCAA All America |
| 2006 | Jenn Bohannan | NJCAA All America |
| 2006 | Courtney Highsmith | NJCAA All America |
| 2006 | Ali Napolitano | NJCAA All America |
| 2006 | Kristine Schafer | NJCAA All America |
| 2005 | Jenny Deans | NJCAA All America |
| 2005 | Jenn Gappert | NJCAA All America |
| 2005 | Kristen Kibler | NJCAA All America |
| 2005 | Jen Marshall | NJCAA All America |
| 2004 | Jenny Deans | NJCAA All America |
| 2004 | Kim Evans | NJCAA All America |
| 2004 | Jenn Gappert | NJCAA All America |