2012
Elaine Nescio - P - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America

2006
Danielle Martinez - C - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Danielle Martinez - C - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Kristie Hurman - P - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Kristie Hurman - P - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Amber Stapler - INF - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Christina Bales - INF - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America

2005   
Danielle Martinez - C - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Danielle Martinez - C - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Amber Stapler - INF - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Amy Bush - OF - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Ashley Kimble - INF - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Cortnie Huggins - DP/UT - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

2004   
Kristi Forrester - P - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Stephanie Stoll - UT - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

2003   
Tina Willis - P - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Denise Schultheis - P - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Jessica Griffith - At Large - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Tina Willis - At Large - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Denise Schultheis - At Large - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Christina Bounelis - At Large - Louisville Slugger/NFCA NJCAA Division III Third Team All-America

2002   
Kristen Bishoff - INF - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Jennifer Bounelis - B - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

2001   
Stacy Smith - B - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Sharie Neptune - INF  NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

2000   
Crystal Bassford - OF   NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Stacy Smith - INF - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Amy Shacklock - P - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

1999   
Crystal Bassford - OF - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Jen O'Neil - INF - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Amy Shacklock - P - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

1988   
Tracy Mrazeck - INF - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Maria Drury - OF - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

1997   
Chris Napora - INF - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America
Sam Miller - P - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America
Brianna Weidman - OF -NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America

1996   
Samantha Miller - P - NJCAA Division III Honorable Mention All-America

1995
Alicia Conine - INF - NJCAA Division III Honorable Mention All-America

1994   
Stacy Reynolds - P - NJCAA Division III Honorable Mention All-America

1988   
Julie Lynn Wooden - C - NJCAA Division III First Team All-America

1986   
Sharon McCallister - OF - NJCAA Division III Second Team All-America